Joint Venture 397 398 2011: Arbitration Clause, SPV And Oppression Test

Indian Company Law
Joint Venture 397 398 2011: Arbitration Clause, SPV And Oppression Test

JV Agreement And Companies Act: Which One Wins   

Companies Act and AoA govern SPV. JV Agreement is private contract. If JV says "2 directors each", but AoA says "directors retire by rotation", AoA prevails. But parties often act on JV for years. They waive AoA by conduct. Emails change terms. Then one party relies on AoA to take control. This creates conflict. CLB must decide if conduct amounts to oppression.    

Courts have said: do not give technical interpretation. Look at reality. If SPV was created only to implement JV, then JV understanding is relevant to decide if majority acted oppressively. Arbitration Clause: Does It Kill 397/398 Petition     

Majority’s first defense: JV has arbitration. So petition not maintainable. Law is clear. Arbitration is for disputes between parties to agreement. 397/398 is statutory remedy for oppression in company. Jurisdiction is different. Supreme Court has held that statutory remedy is not barred by arbitration.     

But CLB will not decide contract damages. It will decide: was allotment oppressive, was removal of director oppressive, was business run prejudicially. So arbitration and 397/398 can run parallel.

The Hypothetical: Where Did It Go Wrong    

In our case, foreign partner invested more because Indian partner could not. That by itself is not oppression. It is business. 

Oppression starts if:

Capital increase was done without notice to Indian partner to defeat him. 

Valuation was arbitrary to wipe out Indian stake. 

Board was reconstituted ignoring earlier understanding, and AoA was amended overnight.

IP was taken out of SPV to parent, leaving SPV as shell.    

If all these happened after trust broke, CLB can say it is oppression. If it was genuine need for funds and procedure was followed, CLB will dismiss. 

Practical Guidance For JV Partners

Drafting: Align JV Agreement with AoA. Put JV terms in AoA as special rights. Documentation: Don’t run JV only on emails. Pass board resolutions to record waivers. 

Exit Clause: Put buy-sell clause in JV. That avoids 397/398. 

Before Filing: See if remedy is contract or company. If only money claim, go to arbitration. If control, dilution, board is issue, go to CLB. 

Minority must show "harsh and burdensome" conduct in SPV. Mere disagreement on expansion is not enough.

Conclusion    

Joint venture 397 398 arbitration spv cases need facts. CLB will look at JV to understand background, but will decide based on oppression in SPV. Arbitration clause is not a shield. At Nathan & Associates we tell JV partners: protect yourself in AoA, not just in JV. That is what CLB will ultimately look at.

Nathan & Associates Logo

Providing top-tier legal consultancy with a focus on integrity, excellence, and client success.

facebook
linkedin
twitter
instagram

Quick Links

Law Firm Services

© 2020 Nathan And Associates – All rights reserved.