Striking Off Name From “Contract Roll” Is Retrenchment: Supreme Court 2014 in
Brajesh Singh v. UPSRTC Restores Reinstatement for Driver
The Supreme Court in Brajesh Singh v. U.P. State Road Transport Corporation held that striking off a workman’s name from “contract roll” amounts to retrenchment under Section 6N of U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and non-compliance renders termination void ab initio. The Court on 03.09.2014 set aside High Court judgment that converted reinstatement to compensation, restoring Labour Court award of reinstatement with back wages. Appellant worked as driver for 240+ days but was termed “contractual driver” and his name struck off roll vide order 29.07.2000 without notice or retrenchment compensation. Practically, what we have seen is that UPSRTC labels drivers as “contractual” to avoid Section 6N UPID Act, equivalent to Section 25F ID Act. Supreme Court said mere use of word “contractual” doesn’t prove contract employment if workman completed 240 days. This blog explains Punjab Land Development Corporation v. Presiding Officer (1990) 3 SCC 682, why Haryana State Electronics v. Mamni (2006) 9 SCC 434 distinguished, and how Brajesh Singh applies Section 6R overriding effect.
Facts: Driver Worked 240+ Days, UPSRTC Struck Off Name From Contract Roll Without Section 6N Compliance, HC Gave Compensation Only
Brajesh Singh worked as driver in UPSRTC, completed 240 days continuous service.Termination order 29.07.2000 stated “contractual driver” and struck off name from contract employees roll. No one month notice or retrenchment compensation under Section 6N UPID Act paid. Labour Court held termination = retrenchment, non-compliance of Sections 6N, 6R, 6Q rendered order void, awarded reinstatement + backwages. High Court set aside, relying on Haryana State Electronics Development Corporation Ltd. v. Mamni (2006) 9 SCC 434, granted consolidated damages equivalent to retrenchment compensation from engagement to disengagement. The Supreme Court in State Bank of India v. N. Sundara Money (1976) 1 SCC 822 held termination for any reason except punishment = retrenchment. The Supreme Court in Punjab Land
Development Corporation v. Presiding Officer (1990) 3 SCC 682 held striking off name from muster roll without Section 25F compliance is illegal retrenchment. In Brajesh Singh, UPSRTC didn’t prove contract. The Supreme Court in Anoop Sharma v. Executive Engineer, PHED (2010) 5 SCC 497 held burden on employer to prove exception to retrenchment. A common mistake clients make is accepting “contractual” label in termination order. Brajesh Singh says look at 240 days service, not nomenclature. For workmen, prove 240 days. For UPSRTC, produce contract if pleaded.
Section 6R UPID Act Has Overriding Effect: Supreme Court Says Sections 6N, 6Q Prevail Over All Laws Supreme Court noted Section 6R UPID Act gives overriding effect to Sections 6J to 6Q. Section 6N, equivalent to Section 25F ID Act, mandates: 1. One month notice or pay, 2. Retrenchment compensation 15 days’ pay per year, 3. Notice to Government. Non-compliance renders retrenchment void ab initio per State of Bombay v. Hospital Mazdoor Sabha AIR 1960 SC 610. The Supreme Court in Krishna Bahadur v. Purna Theatre (2004) 8 SCC 229 held Section 25F mandatory; violation = reinstatement. The Supreme Court in Anup Sharma (2010) 5 SCC 497 reiterated termination without Section 25F compliance void. In Brajesh Singh, UPSRTC admitted no notice/pay given. Labour Court rightly held termination void. High Court erred in applying Mamni (2006) 9
SCC 434 which dealt with daily wagers engaged without sanctioned post. Here
appellant worked 240+ days on regular need. The Supreme Court in Hari Nandan Prasad v. FCI (2014) 7 SCC 190 distinguished Mamni: reinstatement proper if post exists and 240 days proved. In our experience, High Courts mechanically apply Mamni to deny reinstatement. Brajesh Singh says check 240 days + post. For workmen, plead regular nature of work. For UPSRTC, prove fixed-term contract under Section 2(oo)(bb).
Mere Mention “Contractual Driver” Doesn’t Prove Contract: Supreme Court Says Employer Must Prove Exception Under Section 2(oo)(bb)
UPSRTC argued appellant was “contractual driver”, hence Section 2(oo)(bb) ID Act exception applies. Supreme Court rejected: “Merely because the words mentioned as 'contractual driver' in the termination order... does not automatically prove that he has worked as the driver on contract basis.” The Supreme Court in Morinda Coop. Sugar Mills v. Ram Kishan (1995) 5 SCC 653 held Section 2(oo)(bb) exception must be pleaded and proved by employer with contract showing fixed term. The Supreme Court in S.M. Nilajkar v. Telecom District Manager (2003) 4 SCC 27 held if work is perennial, Section 2(oo)(bb) not attracted. In Brajesh Singh, UPSRTC produced no contract. Work of driver perennial. The Supreme Court in Haryana State F.C.C.W. Store Ltd. v. Ram
Niwas (2002) 5 SCC 654 held nomenclature not decisive; nature of work matters. Labour Court finding that termination = retrenchment based on evidence. High Court couldn’t re-appreciate facts under Article 226 per Syed Yakoob v. K.S. Radhakrishnan AIR 1964 SC 477. A common mistake clients make is not challenging “contractual” label. Brajesh Singh says employer must prove contract. For workmen, deny contract, demand production. For UPSRTC, keep contracts if fixed-term.
Conclusion
Brajesh Singh v. U.P. State Road Transport Corporation establishes that Section 6N UPID Act retrenchment contract driver Brajesh Singh UPSRTC Supreme Court 2014 jurisprudence treats striking off name from contract roll as retrenchment if 240 days completed. Supreme Court 03.09.2014 restored reinstatement, holding non-compliance of Section 6N renders termination void per Punjab Land Development Corporation (1990) 3 SCC 682. Section 6R gives overriding effect. Mamni (2006) 9 SCC 434 distinguished. As the law stands, mere “contractual” label insufficient; employer must prove Section 2(oo)(bb). For Labour Courts, check 240 days + compliance. For drivers, claim retrenchment if 240 days done. For UPSRTC, follow Section 6N or face reinstatement. The Supreme Court’s ruling in Brajesh Singh prevents misuse of “contract” nomenclature to defeat Section 6N.