You Did Not Commit the Crime - Can You Still Be Criminally Liable?

Criminal Law
You Did Not Commit the Crime - Can You Still Be Criminally Liable?

Introduction

Criminal law generally focuses on the person who commits the offence. But what happens when another person encourages, assists or facilitates the conduct without physically carrying it out?

The law of abetment addresses this important question. It recognises that criminal conduct can sometimes involve more than the person who performs the final act.

What Makes Abetment Different?

Abetment is not simply association with an offender. The law requires conduct falling within the statutory forms of abetment, such as instigation, intentional aid or participation in the manner recognised by law.

This distinction is crucial because otherwise ordinary friendship, business association or knowledge of another person's activities could potentially be mistaken for criminal participation.

Evidence of Participation

Communications, financial assistance, instructions, planning, logistical support and other conduct may become relevant depending upon the allegation.

However, the prosecution must connect the accused's conduct with the alleged offence in accordance with the statutory requirements.

The Danger of Guilt by Association

One of the most important safeguards in abetment cases is that association should not be confused with criminal participation.

A person may know an accused without encouraging or facilitating an offence. Criminal liability requires the legally required connection.

Conclusion

Abetment recognises that criminal responsibility can extend beyond the person who physically commits an offence. But it does not make every associate of an accused criminally liable.

The central question is whether the individual's conduct satisfies the statutory requirements of abetment and can be connected to the offence through legally sufficient evidence.

Nathan & Associates Logo

Providing top-tier legal consultancy with a focus on integrity, excellence, and client success.

facebook
linkedin
twitter
instagram

Quick Links

Law Firm Services

© 2020 Nathan And Associates – All rights reserved.